When Foreign Officials Visit Saudi Private Girls Colleges

During his visit to Saudi Arabia last week, British PM David Cameron made a stop at Dar Al-Hekma College (DAH) in Jeddah. The private girls college held a roundtable with students and alumnae to welcome the visitor from England.

Private higher education institutions in Jeddah have become a usual stop on the schedules of foreign dignitaries who come to Saudi Arabia in recent years. US Secretary of State Hillary Clinton had a large town hall meeting with students at DAH when she visited the country in February 2010.

In both occasions, the Western visitors praised the intelligence and determination of the female students, and in both cases religious conservatives attacked.. well, everyone: the visitors, the colleges and the students.

As soon as photos from Cameron’s roundtable at DAH surfaced online, religious conservatives started spewing venom. Elderly cleric Abdulrahman al-Barrak described the scene of DAH students shaking hands with the British PM as “disgrace, scandalous, and shame.” He said DAH is only interested in “Westernizing Muslim women.”

Nasser al-Omar, another cleric, asked how is it possible for “those who organized, permitted or participated at the meeting of our girls with a Christian official” to be loyal to our religion, country or people?

More people on Twitter made similar remarks, using even coarser language. This prompted a number of DAH students to say that they will file a complaint with the court against what they described as defamation on the social network, according to Saudi Gazette.

When Cameron visit’s to DAH was first announced, Hanan al-Shargi asked: “Why did the private girls colleges in Jeddah become a regular stop for foreign dignitaries?” Why don’t they visit the public King Abdulaziz University (KAU), for example? Are we embarrassed by KAU students, or is their English not good enough? she added.

Those questions should probably be directed at those foreign officials, but let me take a shot at guessing some answers.

First, there is the political gain that Western politicians can easily achieve by such visits.

When Cameron visits Jeddah and meets with the students, he can come back to tell his parliament that he did not just go to Saudi Arabia to sell arms and ignore their dismal record on human rights. He can go back to London and say that he didn’t just discuss human rights with the Saudi government, he has actually met non-government actors and visited a girls college known for empowering women.

Second, logistics and bureaucracy. Most of these visits are usually proposed by the embassies of those foreign countries, and for them it is far more easier to deal with a small private college than a big public university where they have to go through a lot of red tape. Speaking to foreign diplomats over the years, many of them told me that public universities remain off limits to them.

The Education Office at the US Embassy in Riyadh has been for years seeking permission to organize activities at local universities to help Saudi students prepare before they fly to the US to study on government scholarships. No permission was granted, despite the fact that more than 70,000 Saudi students are currently seeking degrees in America.

Then, there is the general perception that those small private girls colleges in Jeddah are more liberal and progressives than public higher education institutions in the country. A perception that many people would agree with. Even though these private colleges are women-only, they don’t have a problem welcoming male speakers every once in a while.

Now compare this with the “crisis” in Dammam University two months ago when a German female professor entered the engineering building of the male students and gave her first lecture in the semester to the students who were apparently freaking out. Some of them reported the incident to the dean who asked the professor to leave the classroom immediately. It turned out that the professor was confused about her schedule, and that she is only supposed to teach female students.

This is one of these these issues that is a non-issue, really. But then again, it is the kind of thing that conservatives enjoy the most: an issue that involves women, especially one where they don’t have to worry about a direct confrontation with the government.

In the end, it is the control of the social arena that they seek the most. As long as they don’t choose to challenge the government, the government would gladly let them have it.

About these ads

4 thoughts on “When Foreign Officials Visit Saudi Private Girls Colleges

  1. I have the utmost respect for Islam, and certainly a great deal of awe as well as love for the many Saudi students (both men and women) to whom I have taught English in the last four years here in New Hampshire in the USA. I have also hosted dozens of Saudis as well as been the American grandmother to a half dozen so who have lived in my home during their student days here. I feel so embarrassed for my young Saudi friends as they often must attempt to defend their government officials. The naive, impulsive actions and often childish-sounding remarks made by these officials do no good for KSA’s reputation which is so often misunderstood around the world already.

    It is curious, for one, with so many Saudis studying the English language around the world, that even the most rational comments by the KSA government are not edited into intelligent-sounding English before going into print or the Internet. Too, I wonder why the impulsivity of some officials isn’t checked first for the impact their comments will have on the rest of us on the planet. Surely stories like the professor’s simple schedule mistake could have been quickly assessed for its accuracy and validity before being blurted out in such an immature way!

    Some of us work very hard to promote world peace, and it is so easily sabotaged by careless remarks, poorly articulated and too quickly blurted out.

  2. I heard about all the fuss in the media about Cameron visit, and as a Saudi I can’t help it but think when are we gonna grow up and prioritize with our current affairs. Plain and simple what was the big deal about his visit, shaking the women hands or looking at em as if he is at a dance club !! and even if some folks were right in terms of where the religion stands regarding gender mixing and hi5ing, do we really need to point out in the media that this was bad when tons of important things are obviously ignored such as education making us looking like a bunch of retards. I’m sick and tired of those ppl who are always dragging us bad from what’s good for us and always shouting westernization without understanding a thing they are saying when we are simply trying to bring about good for our society .. .. good article man .. enjoyed much

  3. This is an issue of class. These private girls colleges are educating women who will expect to drive in USA, Malaysia, Pakistan etc. After English Speaking International Schools, parents will settle for these other private schools, because there are lots of ex-pats in Jeddah. There are degrees of separation in these types of schools. I noticed that moslem ex-pats from UK had distinct difficulties in getting their
    children places in the International Schools.

    In the UK Cameron backs a system completely different from that of France. Post revolutionary France said the elite had to get out to the provinces and teach every one. In the UK, Cameron is more about elitist teaching for the elite.

    I really thank you for pointing out the situation in 2012 and appreciate your blog.

Comments are closed.