Haia Joins the Modern Age

When did the Commission for Promotion of Virtue and Prevention of Vice (Haia) launch their “Precrime Unit,” a la Stephen Spielberg’s Minority Report? I must have missed the announcement in the middle of this deafening debate over gender mixing.

In a decision that was justified by claiming it was doing the women a favor, the Haia’s branch in Al-Mujaradah has banned women from jogging and other physical exercise in certain areas of this Asir town, south of the country. The decision was based, according to an anonymous Haia source, on records from the commission that described one particular street in the town where women were banned as lonely, poorly lighted, and frequented by drug addicts and other anti-social people. However, this was disputed by one jogger, R.S Al-Shahri, who claimed that the street was safe and well-lit, while almost 30 women would walk there between sunset and Isha prayers.

You can say that this decision by Haia is part preemptive strike, part blaming the victim. Instead of watching these so-called unsafe areas and protect the women by arresting people who attempt to harass them, they go and prevent women from exercising there. Now of course this kind of behavior is not at all new or surprising on the part of Haia, but it happens that we are finally at a time when the Commission can get questioned over some of their actions. What used to be taboo in the past i.e. criticizing the CPVPV, is now a daily practice in the local media.

One of the latest examples comes from al-Madina daily, written by none other than a granddaughter of the Kingdom’s founder. Princess Basma bint Saud, who blogs here, wrote a scathing column calling the Haia to get their act together, telling them that fighting corruption starts from within, and that they should spend their time investigating the theft of public money instead of chasing women and men in barbaric fashion that was not ordered by God or his messenger. Interesting by her royal highness, so very interesting.

About these ads

7 Comments

  1. Mohamed S.
    Posted Saturday, May 1, 2010 at 21:12 | Permalink

    This could all be cleared up if someone provided a picture of said street.

  2. Posted Sunday, May 2, 2010 at 3:34 | Permalink

    I would like to bet that someone is selling home exercise equipment and trying to ban all activities outside so he would sell more :)

  3. Posted Sunday, May 2, 2010 at 18:46 | Permalink

    nothing new here,
    PVPV don’t allow anything just because of few bad seeds in the society.

    they just make it easy on them and hard on us the people.

  4. Posted Monday, May 3, 2010 at 3:07 | Permalink

    I thought the PVPV provided exercise by getting everybody to run
    away
    very fast
    whenever they are approaching?

  5. Laylah
    Posted Monday, May 3, 2010 at 5:30 | Permalink

    Lol, Aafke you are right!
    Usually they are too fat or too old to catch up though :)

  6. Posted Tuesday, May 4, 2010 at 23:35 | Permalink

    advice:
    if you go into a mall make sure where is the nearest exit, you never know when you are going to start running

  7. Muneeb
    Posted Thursday, May 6, 2010 at 21:50 | Permalink

    Wht? WTH? They dont allow exercise in schools n now they’re forbidden on the streets.? -.-

8 Trackbacks

  1. [...] Jeans, who points out joggers in the area have stated the street is both well-lit and safe, likens the decision to one of a futuristic “pre-crime” unit: You can say that this decision by Haia is part preemptive strike, part blaming the victim. [...]

  2. [...] Jeans, who points out joggers in the area have stated the street is both well-lit and safe, likens the decision to one of a futuristic “pre-crime” unit: You can say that this decision by Haia is part preemptive strike, part blaming the victim. [...]

  3. [...] Jeans schrijft dat de straat volgens joggers uit de buurt goed verlicht en veilig is en vergelijkt de beslissing met die van een futuristische misdaadeenheid met voorspellende gaven: Je zou kunnen zeggen dat deze beslissing door Haia deels een preventieve actie is, en deels een [...]

  4. [...] Straße sowohl für gut beleuchtet als auch für sicher halten, fühlt sich an eine futuristische “Pre-Crime”-Einheit erinnert: Man kann sagen, diese Entscheidung der Haia ist Teil eines Präventivschlags, der dem [...]

  5. [...] Saudi Jeans, der darauf hinweist, dass Jogger aus der Gegend die Straße sowohl für gut beleuchtet als auch für sicher halten, fühlt sich an eine futuristische “Pre-Crime”-Einheit erinnert: [...]

  6. [...] [...]

  7. [...] mitatitra fa raha araka ny hevitr'ireo mpihazakazaka eo dia  mazava sy milamina ilay toerana, mampitaha ity fanapahan-kevitra ity amina singa iray ho “fisorohana ny herisetra” amin'ny ho…: Afaka miteny ianao fa ity fanapahan-kevitra noraisin’ny Haia ity dia fandraisana anjara ho [...]

  8. By Nowhere to Run | Benjamin Joffe-Walt on Monday, August 16, 2010 at 10:33

    [...] them from jogging, while Ahmed Al-Omran, arguably Saudi Arabia’s most influential blogger, called it “blaming the victim.” He wrote: “Instead of watching these so-called unsafe areas and [...]

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 42,400 other followers